Judge changes bail conditions for suspect
by Linda Payne
5 months ago | 3412 views | 16 16 comments | 14 14 recommendations | email to a friend | print
Bond has been modified for a Lenoir man who admitted that he violated the conditions of his pre-trial release.

William Howard Shore, 78, of Lincoln Lane, Lenoir is accused of taking indecent liberties with a minor. He was found to be in possession of several photographs that showed the alleged victim, who was 8 years old at the time, topless. He was arrested in September 2009 and ordered not to have any contact with the victim and her family.

During court Wednesday, Assistant District Attorney Lori Goins asked Superior Court Judge Beverly Beal to revoke Shore’s bond because he has had repeated contact with the victim’s family. She argued that Shore has been to the victim’s home on numerous occasions and bought the family groceries. She also alleged that Shore was meeting the victim’s family at another location.

To support her argument, Goins called Diane Osborne to the stand. Osborne is Shore’s step-daughter, and she testified that Shore told her about the contact. She said her step-father has been eating dinner with the family since being ordered not to in September 2009. She also detailed a visit she made to Shore’s house when she saw the alleged victim running from the home and Shore coming out a different door. In addition, Osborne stated that Shore had intentions of giving the victim a car.

“Your honor, this man knows the conditions of his release and violated them; there should be consequences,” Goins said. “He has repeatedly came into contact with the victim, and we would ask you to revoke his bond. He should not be in contact with the victim in a case that is sexual in nature.”

However, Blair Cody, defense attorney, argued that Shore only had contact with the family when they invited him over. He questioned the victim’s father about that contact, discussing times he ordered pizza and asked Shore to pick it up, as well as the fact that Shore helped secure a job for the victim’s father. While discussing various visits with Shore, Cody asked the victim’s father if his daughter had spent the night at Shore’s house since September, and he answered “no.” However, when Goins asked the very same question, the victim’s father stated that she had.

In addition, Cody argued that Shore is suffering some memory loss and may not fully understand the terms of his release. He pointed out inconsistencies with Shore’s comments and how Shore doesn’t always remember who Cody is. He also told the court that the alleged photographs were located under the sink under some cleaners by some family members. He also said Shore was questioned by officers at the Lenoir Police Department while he was recovering from bypass surgery.

“If we were dealing with a 35-year-old man, I could see a harsher verdict, but this a 78-year-old man with some memory loss,” Cody said as he paced behind his assigned table. “He has no family to care for his residence or his dogs. We don’t deny that he violated the conditions, but I don’t think that violation was willful.”

Beal denied Goins’ motion to revoke bond, but he did modify it. Shore was released Wednesday on a $45,000 unsecured and $5,000 secured bond. The original bond was $50,000 unsecured. He also stressed the importance of the pretrial conditions. He presented Shore with a physical copy of his conditions - which include no contact with the victim and her family, abide by a curfew of 8 p.m. to 4 a.m. and to not leave Caldwell, Catawba or Burke counties. He also told the victim’s father that he is not to call Shore or have any contact with him outside work because if he does, Shore may go to jail.

“I have taken into consideration the preliminary evaluation of this defendant, but he does work daily,” Beal said. “This is a not a matter of a person who is unable to provide for his defense, but the court has to fashion a remedy that will prevent this problem, which is why I am going to modify the bond. I don’t think it is right to revoke the bond because he is not a danger to society or a flight risk, but there is to be no more contact.”

Shore is expected to go to trial on Monday, July 26, and he has 30 days to complete a forensic examination.

Hood sentencing scheduled for May

A Lenoir man who pleaded guilty to several felonious charges during this week’s Superior Court administrative session will be sentenced during the week of May 3.

Joshua Michael Hood, 19, of 518 Cottrell Hill Road, Lenoir, pleaded guilty to two counts indecent liberties with a minor, felony possession of cocaine and felony possession of marijuana. Hood is facing a possible maximum sentence of 98 months in prison.

The charges against Hood stem from two separate incidents. He is accused of having inappropriate relations with a 12-year-old between March and April 2008. He also was charged with the drug violations in November 2008 when narcotics officers with the Lenoir Police Department found drug paraphernalia throughout his home and seized approximately .25 grams of illegal drugs and ammunition from inside his house.

During the hearing, Daniel Fulkerson, defense attorney, argued that the brief relations between Hood and the victim were consensual and that Hood didn’t turn 18 until a month later. He also said that while the two incidents were unrelated, the alleged drug use may have been an influence.

Superior Court Judge Beverly Beal, who accepted the plea as written, said he is waiting for the results of a pre-sentencing evaluation before making his ruling. He did say, however, that Hood must have no contact with the victim, not leave Caldwell or Catawba counties and possess no child pornography. He also must abide by a 9 p.m. to 6 a.m. curfew and possess no weapons.

“These conditions are very important,” Beal advised Hood. “If you violate any portion of the conditions, it would result in you being held without bond until the sentencing hearing.”
comments (16)
« mstrawn1991 wrote on Thursday, Mar 25 at 10:34 AM »
Yes...findthefacts...we know.
« findthefacts wrote on Tuesday, Mar 16 at 02:55 PM »
In reading the posts thus far, I see there are several of you that actually know Mr. Shore. I would suggest if you know Mr. Shore and his character that you contact his attorney. His attorney is Blair Cody in Hickory, NC.
« ImAlwaysRight wrote on Friday, Mar 12 at 09:56 AM »
Also to Monarchlady....you don't need to pray for Mr. Shore's salvation. He has been a Christian since before going to fight in the Korean War. He has attended church all of his life, has sung gospel music his whole life, he was choir director for many years at his church until impaired hearing prevented him from continuing. His nightly ritual before bed is to spend time in his Bible and in prayer. It's not his salvation you need to pray for....what you do need to pray for is that God will continue to strengthen Mr. Shore as he endures this attack from Satan. He is holding up well....he has a peace about him that passeth all understanding, because he KNOWS that His God walks with him through this valley.
« ImAlwaysRight wrote on Friday, Mar 12 at 09:47 AM »
To Monarchlady....you are correct when you say that only one man, Jesus, was above sin. But you must also remember that it is just not in some people's character to do this type of crime that Mr. Shore has been accused of. If you don't believe that, then you'd have to admit that you yourself would be capable of it. Since I'm quite sure that you would say that you would never do something like this, then you have to agree that there are also others who would never do something like this either. And, since I personally know this man, and you don't, then I feel more than qualified to say that he would NEVER do what he's been accused of. It would be best for those who know nothing about the people involved or the facts of the situation to keep their opinions to themselves...all your doing is hurting people you don't even know.
« mstrawn1991 wrote on Thursday, Mar 11 at 06:57 PM »
NOT THIS MAN WITH THIS SIN
« monarchlady wrote on Thursday, Mar 11 at 06:17 PM »
Only one man was above sin Jesus Christ,please remember sin is the nature of man. Pray for this man's salvation.
« GNM1979 wrote on Thursday, Mar 11 at 12:21 PM »
I think it is a shame and a disgrace that our newspapers and other news media are allowed to publish not only the names, but also the photographs of persons charged (charged-not convicted) of such crimes as this. The "victims" names and photographs are not given to protect the "innocent"....but what happened to the notion that in America people are to be considered innocent until PROVEN guilty. No matter the outcome of any case such as this, the person charged will always be associated with this charge. Their reputation and good name is ruined. Why can't our newspapers and other news media grant these people the same rights....and only publish names and photographs AFTER being convicted? This man is now being convicted in the court of public opinion by people who have no clue what the actual charges are, what the evidence might be, or anything about this situation or this man. I think it's high time our newspaper gave the same courtesy to ALL people involved in cases until the outcome has been determined. SHAME ON YOU LINDA PAYNE AND LENOIR NEWS TOPIC!!!
« mstrawn1991 wrote on Thursday, Mar 11 at 10:06 AM »
AMEN to ImalwaysRight! One of the most heinous crimes in our community is the crime against children. There isn't a "big murder case" for our DA to try, so he has to go with the next "best" thing to improve his image!

It seems to me Sunshine has already tried and convicted Mr. Shore. But she was right on one thing...SHE (i assume) doesn't know all the facts!
« ImConcerned wrote on Thursday, Mar 11 at 10:05 AM »
I too would like to respond to "Sunshine". It's sad to hear that you don't know anyone who doesn't have so called skeletons in their closets. I also have known Mr. Shore for many, many years. In fact, I have strived to be more like him and the way he lives his life. I only hope that I could be half as caring, compassionate, humble, generous, and just a downright GOOD person as he is. It's also sad that our society doesn't have more people like Mr. Shore...but instead we have far more condemning, critical, suspicious, people who just cannot understand that there truly are good people like Mr. Shore out there. I for one do not believe a word of the so called charges against Mr. Shore. It's a shame that our society has reached the point where we consider people guilty until proven innocent. It just goes to show that the simplest and most innocent of situations can be blown out of proportion and made into something ugly....but unfortunately that's how our society thinks. It's this same way of thinking that prevents our school teachers from being able to pat a student on the back and say "good job" because it would be considered "inappropriate contact".

Sunshine...I hope one day you have the opportunity to meet Mr Shore....or at least someone like him. You're life will be more blessed because of it.
« ImAlwaysRight wrote on Thursday, Mar 11 at 09:41 AM »
I would like to respond to Sunshine's comments. First of all, believe it or not, not everybody has skeleton's in their closets. There are good, godly people in this world, though most people are far too suspicious or sceptical to believe that. As I stated before, I have known this man for nearly 50 years. And I KNOW he would never do anything like what he has been accused of. I would be as apt to believe this about Billy Graham as I would Mr. Shore. He is the kindest, most generous person I've ever known. He would give you the shirt off his back or the last dollar in his pocket if he thought you needed it. I can honestly say that I have never heard him make a negative comment about anyone, he has never told a joke that could even remotely be considered off-color. He sees the good in everybody...he doesn't look for the good in people like the rest of us try to do...he just sees it. You ask anyone who knows Mr. Shore and they will tell you the same thing. And they will also tell you that they don't believe a word of these lies. After talking with him about this situation, he holds no animosity towards his step-daughter nor anyone involved. How many of us could say that? Probably few...but he is the most forgiving person I've ever known in my life. I know the motives behind this whole thing...and they are not out of concern to do the right thing...they are completely motivated by selfishness and vindictiveness. It hurts me to know that such a good godly man can have his reputation ruined by such vile people, and once Mr. Shore is proven innocent I wonder if the paper will be so quick to put that in the paper to try and help clear his name. How many have already judged him as guilty simply because they believe there must be evidence so he must be guilty. Let's not forget...this is an election year, so our elected officials are out to make a big name for themselves before election day, regardless of how many innocent people might get crushed in the process. Mr. Shore's kindness to this family has been taken advantage of, and the jealousy, guilt and vindicitveness of his own so called "family members" involved are what has brought this whole thing about. The things I've said here are not my opinions...these are based on first hand knowledge and all I can say to those behind this is God help them for what they've done.
« sunshine226 wrote on Wednesday, Mar 10 at 12:32 PM »
I would also like to state that it doesn't matter how Godly a person is or much of a Chrisitan they are. Do you people ever watch the News? 90% of our kids they are being messed with is from a family member, friend of the family, pastors, school teachers, baseball coaches, etc... The list goes on & on...& you hear it all the time. It's every where, from big towns to lil cities. Me having kids myself I would just like to know what kind of parents this lil girl has. I don't care how well you know someone you don't let a 8 year old girl spend the night with some 78 year old man that isn't even family. So what does that say about the family & how they are raising there childern.
« sunshine226 wrote on Wednesday, Mar 10 at 12:25 PM »
I just want to state that it doesn't matter how well you know a person or much of a up standing citizen they are. Everyone has skeltons in there closet. Not saying that he's guilty or not...it's not for me to decide, it will all come out eventually. Also the fact that his family is envolved...well people what would you do if this was one of your own family members. You just ignore everything because there family or do you stand up for what you beleive in & tell the truth, & do what's right? Also this is just a news article & I'm sure not all the facts & evdience is stated in the newspaper. Apparently they have enough info on Mr. Shore to feel like he has done something wrong, you don't get arrested for no reason. So before everyone goes out there & gossips & points fingers:: knows all the facts :::
« pcm27 wrote on Tuesday, Mar 09 at 05:55 PM »
I've known this man all my life and know him to be one of the finest people I've ever met. It is truly sad that a man such as he must suffer through the ordeal of proving himself innocent when it appears through the actions of the child's own family that he has done nothing wrong. As the previous posted stated, if this is true why has the family continued their friendship with him? All this is going to accomplish is ruin this man financially and destroy his, until now, spotless reputation....not to mention what will become of the child once the lawyers are through with her.
« mstrawn1991 wrote on Tuesday, Mar 09 at 04:29 PM »
I've known this man my entire life. He grew up in church, fought for his country, sang in a gospel quartet, and lead choir at his church. There is no other godly man than he, and for his "family" to put him in the situation that he's in, is horrible. What happened to his "christian family" and their Bible beliefs in HONORING THY FATHER AND THY MOTHER? I pray God will prove these people wrong, and that this man can heal, mentally and emotionally.
« Margen wrote on Tuesday, Mar 09 at 03:51 PM »
Ain't no way any of this is true. This mans a good man that'd never do what they're accusing him of. I don't believe a word of it.
« ImAlwaysRight wrote on Tuesday, Mar 09 at 11:22 AM »
I have known this man all of my life...I don't believe these charges and would stake my life on that. I also know this "step-daugher" and know that her motives are vindictive and malicious. If this family truly believed the charges, why would they continue to invite the man over to their home for supper? Would you invite someone to your home if you thought they'd abused your child in any way? Absolutely not! This man is the most godly man I've ever known, and for whatever reason, he is being railroaded. All I can say is God help those who've accused this poor man of this. God knows the truth, even if man doesn't recognize it, and God will make them answer for what they've done.